Corning’s new Apple-like ceramic glass might save your next phone from disaster

crepuscularbrolly

Ars Scholae Palatinae
1,150
Subscriptor++
Corning already makes some damn good glass. I don’t use glass screen protectors anymore, after one cracked and then punctured the screen underneath before I got home to take it off.

I use a case, but I drop my phone literally every day, often times multiple times per day. I work on concrete and tile floors, my apartment has concrete floors, and I drop it off my bike at least weekly. I’ve broken it a couple times, and I had someone maliciously destroy it once, but that is what AppleCare is for. That said, any improvements are welcome, even if their current glass is remarkably strong.
Sounds like you need this phone case:


View: https://www.tiktok.com/@theshoptrendz_/video/7282044926190177541
 
Upvote
-2 (1 / -3)
And then we all (well, nearly all? I have collected no data) immediately wrap the sides and back in protective, soft plastic covers...
yeah the back glass makes little sense for most people. I’m sure my lovely looking iPhone would look no worse in my case with a cheaper and lighter plastic back.
 
Upvote
2 (5 / -3)

Log|k

Smack-Fu Master, in training
20
Ah yes, another year, another miraculous Corning breakthrough destined to finally make shattered screens a thing of the past. I think I’ve been hearing this exact same "revolution in smartphone glass durability" every 2–3 years since the Motorola Droid. Gorilla Glass 1 was going to end screen cracks. So was 2. And 3. And 4. And whatever fusion of animal and material they’re on now.

My iPhone still develops micro-scratches from air and somehow cracks when it falls face up. But hey, maybe this time it'll be different. Maybe
 
Upvote
-2 (12 / -14)
The typical model has been that Apple gets the first run on a new glass technology, and then a year or a few years later everyone else does, in exchange for Apple having front ran some of Corning's development costs to get it first.

Is this basically Ceramic Shield under Corning's marketing name, like Gorilla Glass X was last year's iPhone glass before Ceramic Shield?
 
Upvote
9 (9 / 0)

Echohead2

Ars Legatus Legionis
61,045
It’s been awhile since I’ve cracked a phone screen - the last time was when I took my phone out to take a pic while hiking, and it fell face-down on a rock. I’ve been using screen protectors since, as there are still certain types of impacts a glass screen isn’t going to survive.
This is something I was thinking about. Back in the "early days" (say 2007-2013)...it seemed like every cell phone in use was cracked, broken, or at least scratched. Then it seem to die down some...and these days it seems to be a rather uncommon problem Now...I fully admit this is my anecdotal opinion, but from my personal observations, I would be highly surprised if the rate was the same or higher today, and I suspect it is much lower.

Also somewhat odd that so many of the people mentioning scratches/cracks are Apple. Is that a marketshare thing or something else?
 
Upvote
3 (3 / 0)

Snark218

Ars Legatus Legionis
32,493
Subscriptor
Every new development in gorilla glass promises big jumps in scratch resistance and crack resistance.

Every new iPhone still ends up being plenty susceptible to scratches (I get these plenty from the phone being in my pocket with keys or wallet - already had a screen replacement on my 15 pro for a bad scratch), or cracks (I get these less frequently fortunately but still see it all the time).
Have you tried not putting it in your pocket that also has keys in it?

[eddiemurphypointingathead.jpg]
 
Upvote
6 (8 / -2)

spaceminions

Wise, Aged Ars Veteran
109
Nope, that's sapphire.
Which is what you get in watches, and they can last a lot longer than a phone without scratching. Not sure if it's a dimensions thing.
OSB or plywood sheeting is now pretty standard on construction, whether it be to resist hurricanes or earthquakes. Modern structures are considerably stronger.
Depends how far you go back; our wood is still weaker than it used to be (coarser grained) and stick framing is still less than perfect. Also depends if you care more about meeting standards for the first couple decades or for how well it works after a couple centuries.
This is something I was thinking about. Back in the "early days" (say 2007-2013)...it seemed like every cell phone in use was cracked, broken, or at least scratched. Then it seem to die down some...and these days it seems to be a rather uncommon problem Now...I fully admit this is my anecdotal opinion, but from my personal observations, I would be highly surprised if the rate was the same or higher today, and I suspect it is much lower.

Also somewhat odd that so many of the people mentioning scratches/cracks are Apple. Is that a marketshare thing or something else?
A lot of us just got used to using silicone cases from day 1, or whichever solution we chose. But thinking back as long as they've been around, I think it's always been a higher percentage of iphones cracked than other smart phones.
 
Upvote
6 (7 / -1)
That's not Eddie Murphy 😂

But yeah that'd be nice as a theory but in practice I'm not that organized. I just throw shit in a pocket 🤷‍♂️
Train yourself to put the phone in the same pocket every time, and other stuff in the other pocket. Do it 100 times in a row. The savings from damaged screens will last a lifetime.
 
Upvote
5 (8 / -3)

Heavens

Wise, Aged Ars Veteran
139
Subscriptor
Fancy glassware is all good, but of course you could always get a phone case that provides adequate padding in corners and extends a bit above the rim so the only real way to smash the glass is to drop it face down on a pebble.

Bonus, it makes the phone much less slippery so there are less incidents of phone meeting the floor in general.
Pebbles are the phone screens kryptonite.

I feel we pretty much hit a plateau with glass screens on phones, if we make them any harder they just shatter, if we make them softer they scratch.

The only thing I'm seeing is making it way harder (eg. sapphire glass hard) but I'm not sure if that's feasible for phones.

Gorilla Glass Victus 2 has a hardness of around 670 HV 0.2 while sapphire glass is around 2000 HV.

Not a glass expert though, I mostly deal with steel.
 
Upvote
8 (9 / -1)

Jeff S

Ars Tribunus Angusticlavius
9,864
Subscriptor++
A few years ago I got a scratch on my iPhone 13 Pro, and wanted to have the screen replaced by Apple Care.

They told me scratches aren't covered but broken glass is.

I spent hours trying to break the damn thing by dropping it from different heights. Eventually I hit it with a hammer.

I say that to say this, their screens have been absurdly strong for quite some time.
Translation: We don't cover the damage we know WILL happen, only the damage that we know almost surely won't happen.
 
Upvote
2 (5 / -3)

Jeff S

Ars Tribunus Angusticlavius
9,864
Subscriptor++
Train yourself to put the phone in the same pocket every time, and other stuff in the other pocket. Do it 100 times in a row. The savings from damaged screens will last a lifetime.
Yup. I figured this out about 20 years ago. Made it a habit, and stuck with it.
 
Upvote
4 (4 / 0)
Translation: We don't cover the damage we know WILL happen, only the damage that we know almost surely won't happen.

I dont know about that, they cover theft and other weird things, and you will never get to me speak ill of Apple.
I once went to get a battery replaced on a long out of warranty 8s Plus, they didn't have the battery in stock so they gave me a new ( or I assume refurbished 8s plus) for free

Their support has been good enough that I won't bad mouth them for typical corporate shenanigans.
 
Upvote
9 (10 / -1)

waldo22

Ars Praetorian
556
Subscriptor++
Also fun fact, traditional plaster is also concrete! What we normally call plaster walls in homes is actually the same stuff sidewalks are made out of (Portland cement), but without the pebbles for aggregate (only some sand instead). It's also usually watered down more as it makes it easier to apply and stretches the material a bit, too. Interior walls don't need to be very strong so they'd typically thin it out and add some wood pulp as a binder, or occasionally horse hair. The latter has led to rate cases of people getting anthrax during home projects!
...and due to the metal mesh behind the plaster, plaster walls eat WiFi for breakfast, lunch and dinner.
 
Upvote
9 (9 / 0)
Ah yes, another year, another miraculous Corning breakthrough destined to finally make shattered screens a thing of the past. I think I’ve been hearing this exact same "revolution in smartphone glass durability" every 2–3 years since the Motorola Droid. Gorilla Glass 1 was going to end screen cracks. So was 2. And 3. And 4. And whatever fusion of animal and material they’re on now.

My iPhone still develops micro-scratches from air and somehow cracks when it falls face up. But hey, maybe this time it'll be different. Maybe

I dont know man, I left my 15 Pro on top of my car and drove off. I came back to a phone that only had a few scratches after skittering off the top of my car onto asphalt and being run over.

My personal experience has been that phone screens are in fact getting better. I dont think we'll ever be able to get rid of scratches but the different between phone screens today and 10 years ago is night and day.
 
Upvote
15 (15 / 0)

waldo22

Ars Praetorian
556
Subscriptor++
Also, when my phone inevitably slips out of my hand in the weirdest, physics-defying, Mr. Bean-approved ways possible, it usually follows a healthy arc upwards before even starting to fall.
...and I try to cushion the fall with my foot, but end up drop-kicking it across the parking lot instead. How does Corning test for that?
 
Upvote
8 (8 / 0)

Frodo Douchebaggins

Ars Legatus Legionis
10,744
Subscriptor
Train yourself to put the phone in the same pocket every time, and other stuff in the other pocket. Do it 100 times in a row. The savings from damaged screens will last a lifetime.

Fair, but I should mention I'm also old and lazy. It's not that big of a deal to me.

Pebbles are the phone screens kryptonite.

I feel we pretty much hit a plateau with glass screens on phones, if we make them any harder they just shatter, if we make them softer they scratch.

The only thing I'm seeing is making it way harder (eg. sapphire glass hard) but I'm not sure if that's feasible for phones.

Gorilla Glass Victus 2 has a hardness of around 670 HV 0.2 while sapphire glass is around 2000 HV.

Not a glass expert though, I mostly deal with steel.

I'd be willing to consider a sapphire display phone if we get to the point where phones stop advancing in ways I give a shit about and I'd be keeping it long term.

I beat the shit out of my Apple Watch with a sapphire crystal and it's no worse for wear.
 
Upvote
1 (3 / -2)

Steve austin

Ars Praetorian
881
Subscriptor
Thirty years ago, if you told me that company that makes casserole dishes was going to be a tech giant, I would have said, you're crazy.
Corning sold off its consumer products division (that made CorningWare, Visions, Corelle, and Pyrex kitchenware) just under 30 years ago. They’ve been only commercial/industrial since. And they’ve been ”tech” (if perhaps not a giant) for over 100 years (including making the Mt Polomar observatory mirror blank over 90 years ago).
 
Upvote
17 (17 / 0)

Steve austin

Ars Praetorian
881
Subscriptor
The typical model has been that Apple gets the first run on a new glass technology, and then a year or a few years later everyone else does, in exchange for Apple having front ran some of Corning's development costs to get it first.

Is this basically Ceramic Shield under Corning's marketing name, like Gorilla Glass X was last year's iPhone glass before Ceramic Shield?
And apparently the EU doesn’t like these exclusives and is investing Corning for antitrust violations.
 
Upvote
2 (3 / -1)

Steve austin

Ars Praetorian
881
Subscriptor
Every new development in gorilla glass promises big jumps in scratch resistance and crack resistance.

Every new iPhone still ends up being plenty susceptible to scratches (I get these plenty from the phone being in my pocket with keys or wallet - already had a screen replacement on my 15 pro for a bad scratch), or cracks (I get these less frequently fortunately but still see it all the time).
That’s why my phones are never without a screen protector. They also get scratched, but at 3 for $8 for a top quality tempered glass protector, it’s not a big deal to swap them out every couple of months.
 
Upvote
4 (4 / 0)

Chuckstar

Ars Legatus Legionis
34,800
Pebbles are the phone screens kryptonite.

I feel we pretty much hit a plateau with glass screens on phones, if we make them any harder they just shatter, if we make them softer they scratch.

The only thing I'm seeing is making it way harder (eg. sapphire glass hard) but I'm not sure if that's feasible for phones.

Gorilla Glass Victus 2 has a hardness of around 670 HV 0.2 while sapphire glass is around 2000 HV.

Not a glass expert though, I mostly deal with steel.
IIUC, the point of ceramic glass is that there are islands of hard bits separated by more flexible bits. The hard bits are still close enough together to make scratching difficult. The more flexible bits in between allow flexing under impact.
 
Upvote
5 (5 / 0)

starglider

Ars Scholae Palatinae
979
Subscriptor++
Fun fact: the camera lenses on most phones are synthetic sapphire. It's very hard, and scratches will destroy a lens quickly. It's pretty brittle stuff, though, so glass is still a better option for the display.

For a while, I was strongly anti-case: the phones are thinner and sleeker without anything on them, and I would argue that I'm neither clumsy nor poor so I don't need a case. Turns out that I actually am pretty clumsy, and if I kept having to replace thousand-dollar phones, I'd become poor, so I just started putting everything in Smartish cases and haven't had a damaged display in seven years.
 
Upvote
8 (8 / 0)

XSportSeeker

Ars Scholae Palatinae
880
You know, I don't really wanna take merit away from Corning because they do a really good job with the glass panels and all, it's hard work, and people working there deserves the recognition...
It's just that 2 decades of the same ad piece gets kinda tiring, you know?
What has always "saved me from disaster" is a screen protector and case. And then, of course, taking good care of smartphones and electronics in general.
Glass chemistry, or material engineering for this type of stuff, will always have to strike a balance between hardness and toughness. The unfortunate thing for clumsy people is that you are always putting your glass devices through stresses that ranges from the extremes of one to another.
There's only so much you can do through chemistry, so unless Corning comes out with some transparent metal thing that would be revolutionary not only for smartphone screens but to everything else that uses glass, the differences won't be all that much perceptible, save for anecdotal evidence, which there seems to always be plenty every time something like this is announced.
 
Upvote
1 (1 / 0)

Invid

Ars Praefectus
4,627
Subscriptor
A matte screen and a body that isn't a slip and slide challenge would be great.
I dunno. My last phone was $1800 CAD. I'm ok with paying that but the phone is getting a tempered glass screen protector. They don't work well with matte screens so I prefer smooth and optically sharp, thank you.
 
Upvote
1 (1 / 0)

Random_stranger

Ars Praefectus
4,591
Subscriptor
It's not at all necessary for functionality. They could make the whole phone a little thicker with flush lenses and then make the battery thicker and extend the battery life. But nope, they'd rather let the thing wobble on a table and be annoying.

But then the CEOs couldn't measure their thicks.
 
Upvote
4 (4 / 0)

Random_stranger

Ars Praefectus
4,591
Subscriptor
Or, alternatively, a dedicated phone pouch works - at least for me.

So far, I've never cracked or scratched a screen on any cell phone dating back to the flip phones of yore (1997 or 98). My secret is to always get a case for it (one that protects the body and especially corners), never carry it in a pocket that might get bent (like pants) and I usually use a pouch (or dedicate a vest pocket for it).

I get the impulse to just slide the thing into a front or back pocket, since everything else goes there, too. But at the same time, everything else goes there, too and most of those everything else's are hard enough to damage a screen if enough force is applies. And you can get some pretty high forces from the leverage of fabric alone.

Yes, I can look like a nerd, but that never bothered me in the past. And if the cost of not looking like a nerd means involuntarily having to replace a damaged phone every year or two, I'm fine paying the nerd tax.

Same thing here - hip holster for me. Great protection (I HATE having anymore more than wallet/keys in my pockets!), super safe (I used to have a company phone, with very little chance at replacement - it was a major deal when I accidentally dropped it after 4-5 years and had to take a used one). Plus, if there's anything to the radiation thing, well.. it's a bit further from my jiggly bits.
 
Upvote
2 (2 / 0)

EngineerX

Wise, Aged Ars Veteran
350
The cement! Asphalt is technically a concrete. Technically anything that's a binder (cement) plus aggregate equals "concrete." Fun fact, asphalt is also the most recycled material in the world! Most asphalt you've laid eyes on in your life has been recycled many times.

<rant time>

Also fun fact, traditional plaster is also concrete! What we normally call plaster walls in homes is actually the same stuff sidewalks are made out of (Portland cement), but without the pebbles for aggregate (only some sand instead). It's also usually watered down more as it makes it easier to apply and stretches the material a bit, too. Interior walls don't need to be very strong so they'd typically thin it out and add some wood pulp as a binder, or occasionally horse hair. The latter has led to rate cases of people getting anthrax during home projects!

This is why, if you have plaster walls and have tried drilling into them, you dull your bits very quickly. It feels like you're drilling into rock, because you are! You need to use a masonry bit (or embrace the dullness).

Also fun fact, interior walls are not structural. Older homes with plaster walls are not stronger than drywall homes. House strength comes from the frame and sheeting, for which older homes had inferior shiplap sheeting, compared to modern plywood or OSB. The large rectangular sheets we use now are way more rigid than old wood sheeting. Shiplap sheeting is weak and doesn't prevent racking movement of the frame very well. Older homes may feel more "solid" but make no mistake: should heavy winds or even a small earthquake pass them by, they'll topple.

Plaster is almost never used anymore because it's: more expensive, more labor intensive, more resource intensive to make than drywall. And if you're a homeowner: trust me, you don't want to bother repairing plaster. Drywall is waaaay easier.

The only kind of people who think, "oh yeah plaster repair sounds fun!" are the kind of unhinged people who read the word "asphalt" and then brain dump about all things cementuous materials

Edit: this rant is actually abridged
Plaster is NOT Portland cement. It used to be calcium hydroxide lime and now it's calcium sulphate just like the inside of dri wall
 
Upvote
9 (9 / 0)

EngineerX

Wise, Aged Ars Veteran
350
Which is what you get in watches, and they can last a lot longer than a phone without scratching. Not sure if it's a dimensions thing.

Depends how far you go back; our wood is still weaker than it used to be (coarser grained) and stick framing is still less than perfect. Also depends if you care more about meeting standards for the first couple decades or for how well it works after a couple centuries.

A lot of us just got used to using silicone cases from day 1, or whichever solution we chose. But thinking back as long as they've been around, I think it's always been a higher percentage of iphones cracked than other smart phones.
Screen to the metal edge and flush.
 
Upvote
0 (0 / 0)
I often wonder why they don't make plastic screens with replaceable glass screen protectors. Scratch resistant and smooth to the fingers up top, and shatterproof on the actual expensive screen.
Maybe it doesn't work for some reason (visually less pretty?), or maybe fragile screens drive up profits?
A lot of screens are plastic underneath, they're just laminated to the glass

This dramatically boosts strength, clarity, brightness, and sensitivity to touch

Consumers voted overwhelmingly against plastic (resistive) screens decades ago

Plastic backs however were a manufacturer-led "solution"
 
Upvote
2 (3 / -1)
Every new development in gorilla glass promises big jumps in scratch resistance and crack resistance.

Every new iPhone still ends up being plenty susceptible to scratches (I get these plenty from the phone being in my pocket with keys or wallet - already had a screen replacement on my 15 pro for a bad scratch), or cracks (I get these less frequently fortunately but still see it all the time).
Well you see, iPhones do not use gorilla glass.
 
Upvote
-4 (0 / -4)

silverboy

Ars Scholae Palatinae
1,362
Subscriptor++
And this, kids, is why we don't put our keys or wallet in the same pocket as our phone. Phone in left front, knife and money clip in the right.
Knife?? You mean knives, I put my stabbing knife left front, and my slashing knife right front, like all good people.

WTH.
 
Upvote
6 (6 / 0)

plugh

Ars Centurion
257
Subscriptor++
In its lab tests (PDF), Gorilla Glass Ceramic withstood 10 drops from one meter onto surfaces that closely resemble asphalt. Why Corning does not use real asphalt for this test is unclear.
They probably used a surface with more precisely defined properties. Asphalt properties vary a lot depending on many fabrication variables (And most scientists are not expert in its application). So, they probably looked up it's hardness, roughness, etc. parameters and then bought a pre-made surface with similar values.
 
Upvote
4 (4 / 0)
Fair, but I should mention I'm also old and lazy. It's not that big of a deal to me.



I'd be willing to consider a sapphire display phone if we get to the point where phones stop advancing in ways I give a shit about and I'd be keeping it long term.

I beat the shit out of my Apple Watch with a sapphire crystal and it's no worse for wear.
Pour one put for GTAT and their synthetic sapphire production. RIP
 
Upvote
3 (3 / 0)

taxythingy

Ars Praetorian
468
Subscriptor
... The large rectangular sheets we use now are way more rigid than old wood sheeting. Shiplap sheeting is weak and doesn't prevent racking movement of the frame very well. Older homes may feel more "solid" but make no mistake: should heavy winds or even a small earthquake pass them by, they'll topple. ...
Since you're ranting, I'll be that person...

Earthquakes up to about MM7 will not typically topple an older wood framed house, even with heavy concrete tile roofs. That's without sheet bracing of any kind - just lathe and plaster interiors and weatherboard exteriors. "Shaking-induced structural damage was almost always very minor." BRANZ report on 2010 Canterbury earthquake. That's including many houses built since 1900. Similar performance seen with the later MM6.2 quake almost directly under Christchurch. Yes damage, and lots of it, but no, not toppling or falling over.
 
Upvote
2 (2 / 0)

plugh

Ars Centurion
257
Subscriptor++
Thirty years ago, if you told me that company that makes casserole dishes was going to be a tech giant, I would have said, you're crazy.
Thirty years ago, Corning was already a tech giant. They developed the low loss fiber that made optical fiber communications possible. Corning SMF-28 was the industry standard single mode fiber (the only optical fiber type I still remember by name). Apparently, they also developed and produced the glass for Edison lightbulbs. And many other technological glass products in between.

The consumer kitchenware was the sideline business. Which they sold over 20 years ago.
 
Upvote
8 (8 / 0)